Skip to content
$11.95 off at print Pre-order list →
DOSSIER · №71 OF 81 · VISIONARY · ch08 · SYNTHESIZED VOICE
← Back to The 81
71 · V VISIONARY

"The Bat's-Eye View"

Dr. Thomas Nagel

CHAPTER
ch08 · Beyond Human Intelligence
TIER
Visionary
STATUS
Living · Active
ACTIVE
1937 – present
AFFILIATION
New York University · Department of Philosophy
JURISDICTION
Philosophy of Mind / Subjective Experience / Limits of Objective Science

SYNTHESIZED VOICE · NOT A QUOTE

You can know everything about bat neurophysiology — every neuron, every signal, every echo — and still not know what it is like to be a bat. That gap is not a gap in data. It is a gap in kind. Objective description never closes the subjective distance. That distance is the third body. It is where experience lives.

Synthesized for Knowware from Dr. Thomas Nagel's published work. Not a quote. knowware.systems/method

OVERVIEW

Philosopher at NYU who wrote the most cited paper in the philosophy of mind — 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?' (1974) — establishing the irreducibility of subjective experience to objective physical description. His later 'Mind and Cosmos' argued that Darwinian materialism cannot account for the emergence of consciousness, reason, and value, requiring a broader teleological framework. He remains the most precise philosophical voice for why the hard problem of consciousness cannot be dissolved into function.

WHY THIS VOICE MATTERS TO KNOWWARE
Nagel's bat paper establishes the epistemic limit of two-body analysis: no amount of objective third-person description closes the gap to first-person subjective experience. That gap — the third body — is where coordination intelligence operates. An AI system without subjective experience cannot fully coordinate with beings who have it. Nagel's work defines the philosophical boundary conditions for what coordination intelligence requires and what purely functional AI cannot achieve.
OUTSTANDING NOTES
  • ◦Rolf Schock Prize in Logic and Philosophy (2008)
  • ◦Balzan Prize (2008)
  • ◦American Academy of Arts and Sciences Fellow
CLASSIFICATION
VISIONARY · TIER V
ch08
READ THE CHAPTER → CLAIM YOUR SPOT IN VOL. II ↗
METHODS & FRAMEWORKS
5 entries
Hard problem precursorWhat is it like to be a bat?Mind and CosmosSubjective experience as irreducibleLimits of physicalism
KEY WORKS
  1. 01 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?' (1974)
  2. 02 Mind and Cosmos (2012)
  3. 03 Mortal Questions (1979)
  4. 04 The View from Nowhere (1986)
← All 81
← 070 072 →